
The most common payroll errors before payday are wrong hours, missed leavers and new hires, wrong deductions, and changed bank details. Most of them are caught by a short, deliberate check in the last week before a run goes out. Use this payroll errors before payday checklist to run that check. It gives you a countdown, an owner for each step, and what "done" looks like. The deduction section covers Canadian payroll, which is the focus of this guide, and a short US check sits alongside it for owners who also pay US staff. The checks work in a spreadsheet or in any payroll system, including MatrixHR HR and payroll software. The guide is written for owners who run HR and payroll in-house.
1What are the most common payroll errors before payday?
Most errors come from four places:
- Wrong hours. Missed punches, overtime entered as regular time, or leave approved after the cut-off.
- Missed changes. A new hire who was never set up, a leaver still on the roster, or a rate change that never reached payroll.
- Wrong deductions. An out-of-date tax form, a benefit change that wasn't passed on, or a union deduction that kept running after it should have stopped.
- Changed bank details. A new account for an employee that nobody verified.
None of these needs a sophisticated system to catch. They need a fixed check, on a fixed day, done by someone other than the person who made the change.
Skipping the check costs more than the time it takes. An overpayment is hard to get back, and an underpayment leaves someone short until you fix it.
2How does the payroll errors before payday checklist work?
Run the checklist on a countdown, not on the morning the file goes out. The schedule below starts five working days before payday. It uses working days, so adjust the days to your pay cycle. If your bank needs longer to process a file, move the upload earlier.
| Timing | Step | Owner | What done looks like |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5 working days before payday | Cut-off | Payroll preparer | Pay period closed to new hours; cut-off time written on the run sheet |
| 4 working days before | Hours review | Payroll preparer | Missing punches, overtime and leave checked and fixed or noted |
| 3 working days before | Gross pay variance | Payroll preparer, with operations manager | Every employee over the agreed threshold has a written reason |
| 3 working days before | Deductions check | Payroll preparer | CPP, EI, tax and benefit lines match the records on file |
| 2 working days before | Second approval | Second approver | Approval recorded against the run number, by someone other than the preparer |
| 1 working day before | Bank file check | Person who uploads the file | File total and employee count match the payroll register; account funded |
| Upload day | Release | Person who uploads the file | Release logged with run number, file total and time |
Keep the same countdown every cycle. Consistency is what makes a missed step visible.
Who owns each step?
Name a role for each step, not just a person, so the job survives holidays and staff changes. Four roles cover most small payroll teams:
- Payroll preparer: runs the hours, variance and deductions checks.
- Operations manager: reviews hours and any large variance, since they know why a shift ran long.
- Second approver: the owner or finance lead, who approves the run in the register.
- Uploader: the person who uploads the bank file.
The preparer never approves their own run. If you have only one person in payroll, the owner is the second approver.
3Which hours and punches should you check first?
Hours cause more errors than anything else on this list, so check them first. Clock punches and approved leave feed the run. If either is incomplete on cut-off day, the run pays the wrong amount.
Check four things:
- Missing punches. A clock-in with no clock-out, or the reverse. Fix them against the schedule or the employee's confirmation, and record the fix.
- Unusual overtime. Hours well above the employee's normal week, or overtime in a week that normally has none.
- Leave not yet approved. Decide before the run whether the leave is paid. Unapproved leave left in a run is a common source of overpayment.
- Hours entered after cut-off. These go to the next run. Only include them if the owner signs off a late change and it is noted in the correction log.
If your punches come from ZKTeco time clocks, see ZKTeco attendance to payroll for how punch data is brought into payroll. Whatever tool you use, the preparer should be able to trace every hour on the run back to a punch, a timesheet or an approved leave request.
4How do you compare this run with the last one?
Compare each employee's gross pay with the last run. Most pay changes have a reason you already know about. A change nobody can explain is the one to check before approval.
Agree a threshold with the owner before the run. One option is 10%. Another is a dollar amount, which may suit a business where pay is fairly fixed. The right threshold depends on how much pay normally moves, how much hours vary, and how much time you want to spend on reviews. Anything over the threshold needs a written reason in the register. This gross pay variance check catches hours and rate errors before deductions muddy the picture.
The table below is a hypothetical example, with round figures, to show the method. It is not a benchmark, and the 10% threshold is used only for illustration:
| Employee | Last run gross | This run gross | Change | Over 10%? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employee A | $2,000 | $2,500 | +$500 (+25%) | Yes, check |
| Employee B | $2,000 | $2,100 | +$100 (+5%) | No |
| Employee C | $1,500 | $1,200 | -$300 (-20%) | Yes, check |
Employee A's pay rose by $500. That could be a genuinely heavy week of overtime, or a duplicated timesheet. Employee C's pay fell by $300, which could be unpaid leave that was never entered, or missed punches. Employee B moved by $100, within the threshold, so no note is needed.
5How do you catch a new hire or leaver mistake?
Changes break the process most often, because they happen outside the normal cycle. Check each type before the run.
New hires:
- The pay rate matches the signed offer or contract.
- TD1 federal and provincial forms are on file. Quebec employees complete the TP-1 form for the provincial part.
- Direct deposit details are confirmed, using the call-back routine described below.
Leavers:
- They are removed from the active roster after their last day, so they don't receive a regular cycle.
- Final pay is checked: hours to the last day, any vacation pay owing, and any deductions that should stop.
- A Record of Employment is issued where it is required.
Rate changes:
- Written approval is on file, with an effective date that matches a pay period.
A pay rise agreed in a meeting but never written down is a dispute waiting to happen. If your staff can update some of their own details, a guide to employee self-service portals explains what to build and what to keep under payroll control.
6What Canadian deductions should you check before release?
These checks apply to Canadian employees. Check each line against the employee's records and the current rules.
- CPP and EI. Employee contributions come off each pay. The employer calculates and pays its own CPP and EI shares on the same earnings, but the employer's EI share is not a copy of the employee's premium, so check it separately. Both plans have annual limits that change from year to year. Check the current figures on the CRA's website and look for anyone who has reached a maximum. In Quebec, the Quebec Pension Plan (QPP) applies instead of CPP, and Quebec Parental Insurance Plan (QPIP) premiums are also deducted, so use the Quebec rules for those employees.
- Income tax withheld. This is based on each employee's TD1 forms and the CRA tax tables. If a run falls early in a new year, confirm you are using the new year's tables before the first run.
- Benefit and union deductions. Match each one to the authorised amount and current enrolment. A cancelled benefit that is still being deducted is a wrong deduction.
Amounts withheld are not yours to keep. You remit CPP, EI and income tax to the CRA on a schedule set by how much you withhold, which is usually monthly, quarterly or accelerated. Find your schedule in your CRA business account and set a reminder so the money is ready before it is due.
Confirm current rates, annual maximums and remittance dates with the CRA before you rely on this list. Rules change, and this checklist is not a substitute for current CRA guidance. T4 slips for the year must reach employees and the CRA by the end of February, so check the year's totals against the register in January.
What about payroll deductions in the US?
If you also pay US staff, run the same steps for those employees, using the rules that apply to them. These items are the usual ones to check. Confirm each rate and deadline with the IRS and the relevant state before you rely on it:
- Federal income tax withholding, based on each employee's Form W-4 on file.
- Social Security and Medicare, withheld from employees and matched by the employer.
- Federal unemployment tax, which is paid by the employer.
- State income tax and state unemployment contributions, which vary by state, so check the rules for every state where you have staff.
The approach is the same as the Canadian check: match each line to the records on file, and have a second person confirm it before release.
7Does a balanced payroll total prove the run is correct?
No. A balanced total proves the arithmetic adds up. It does not prove each cheque is right.
Suppose Employee X is overpaid $300 and Employee Y is underpaid $300. The total net pay is exactly what it should be, so a total-only check passes. Both employees are wrong, and one of them will notice first.
Compare by employee instead. For each person, check gross pay, deductions and net pay against the payroll register and the last run. A per-employee comparison catches the offsetting errors a total hides. It takes longer, but it is the check that works.
8Who should approve a payroll run in a small business?
One person prepares the run and a different person approves it. The approval is recorded against the run number, with a date and time. The second approver is the owner or finance lead. In a very small team, the owner approves.
The approver should not redo the preparer's work. They should look at the register for the items most likely to be wrong:
- Every variance flag, with its written reason.
- The new hire and leaver list, checked against HR records.
- Total deductions, checked against the amounts on file.
- The net pay total, which carries forward to the bank file check.
Approval means the approver has looked at these items. It does not mean clicking "OK" on a summary. If a flagged item is unclear, the run waits.
Some teams build approval steps like this into their own systems. Our HR software development service covers that work.
9What should the bank file check cover before upload?
The bank file is the last point where a mistake can be stopped before money leaves. The controls below are recommended practice for a small team, not requirements set by the bank or the CRA.
| Control | What to check | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Total match | File total equals register net pay | Register $50,000; file $50,000 |
| Count match | Number of payees in the file equals the register | 40 employees in both |
| Funding | Payroll account holds the total before release | Balance covers the file total plus any other debits due |
| Changed details | Every new or changed account verified by call-back | No change in the file without a logged call-back |
The figures above are hypothetical. Do the upload only after all four checks pass. Log the file total, the payee count and the time of release.
Changed bank details: the call-back check
A changed bank account is one of the easiest ways to pay the wrong person. The fix is simple, and it is the control most small teams skip.
When an employee sends new account details, do not reply to the email or message that gave the change. Phone the employee on a number already held in HR records from before the request. Confirm the new details on that call, then log the date, the person who confirmed them and the number you used.
If you cannot verify the change before cut-off, keep the existing details for this run and verify the change for the next one. A delayed change costs one cycle. A payment to the wrong account can cost the full amount.
10What do you do when an error is found after approval?
Act in this order:
- If the pay has not left, stop the release. Correct the source data (the timesheet, the rate or the deduction), rerun the register and approve again. Record the new approval.
- If the pay has gone, decide the fix. An underpayment is paid as a correction, ideally on the next run or sooner, with the amount shown on the pay stub.
- If the employee was overpaid, do not recover the money from future wages until you have checked provincial employment standards rules. These rules limit when and how employers can take money back from wages, and they differ by province. Tell the employee in writing: the amount, the cause, how and when you will recover it, and that they can raise questions.
Keep a correction log for every error. Record the employee, amount, cause, fix and the approver who signed it off. After a few cycles, the log shows which errors repeat, and that is where to fix the process.
| Employee | Amount | Cause | Fix | Approver |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Employee D | $100 overpaid | Leave entered as worked hours | Hours corrected; recovery only after a provincial rules check and written notice | Owner |
11How long should you keep payroll records in Canada?
CRA guidance is to keep payroll records for six years from the end of the last tax year they relate to. Keep the payroll register, approval records, correction log and bank file totals in the same archive.
Provincial employment standards and privacy rules can set different requirements for some records, so check your province before you dispose of anything. The ADP Canada guide to payroll records and Employment Hero's Canadian guide both describe the six-year rule. Confirm it against current CRA guidance before you set your own retention policy.
12How do you keep the checklist working?
Run this payroll errors before payday checklist for the next cycle, then tighten it after each run. Each entry in the correction log shows which step needs attention, so fix that step first. The payroll errors before payday checklist that catches mistakes is the one you run the same way every cycle, with a named owner for each step.